Electronic Book Reader – Why, Which, Where?

New generation electronic book reader
Electronic book reader

Electronic book readers aren’t useful because they replicate books, but because they add value to them.

If you are an avid reader, you may find it much more convenient to download books then trying to get them from the bookstore or library. However, sitting in front of a PC monitor to do your reading is usually frustrating experience. Furthermore, notebook and tablet computers are too big and bulky for this simple task, while the most PDAs have too small of a screen for convenient reading.

What we want is a hand-held, portable device that can read a variety of file formats, especially scanned, non-text PDFs. A large screen, long battery life, and good interface are other attributes of a perfect electronic book reader.

Portable Ebook Readers Technology

With its iPod, Apple has demonstrated that millions of people are willing to carry around digital devices with their favorite content. After music, why not novels and nonfiction?

Many experts are convinced that digital books, after plenty of false starts, are finally ready for takeoff. With latest product releases we have definitely went out the infancy stage as the present electronic book readers are stronger, better and more functional then their predecessors, and finally are offering a viable alternative to traditional books.

The most important step forward is introduction of “digital ink”. This innovative display technology also called “electronic paper” solved some key problems. By using a sophisticated method for arranging tiny black and white capsules into words and images with an electronic charge, this advanced technology makes the text on display looks just as sharp as ink on a printed page. Unlike a laptop screen, these screens are non-reflective: The more light that streams down on them, the better they look thus working fine in direct sunlight. At the same time, new technology also significantly reduced the buttery power consumption.

Amazon’s innovation, and it’s a brilliant one, is to use cellular wireless — specifically, a high-speed technology called EVDO that runs over Sprint Nextel Corporation’s nationwide network. This means that you can log on at will from almost anywhere in the country (and surely very soon from anywhere in the world). There are no access charges for using this network; you pay only for any content you download.

Electronic Book Reader – Pros and Cons

To help you decide whether this gadgets are worth your consideration and your money, let’s look at what you get and what you “loose” by opting for such an electronic reading device.

Main Advantages of Ebook Readers

The key of success: portable ebook readers do much more than simply replicating a traditional book.

  • Ebook readers are great devices for sourcing books, the same way you are sourcing music or movies online.
  • They let you downloaded books in less than a minute on to the device and take them with you wherever you go.
  • With most of the devices, best sellers and new releases go for $9.99, meaning they are often significantly cheaper than even discounted hardcover print versions.
  • Thanks to electronic book reader’s generous memory capacity, you may have your entire library of books and a dictionary available at all times, at hand, in your pocket.
  • By implementing sophisticated technologies like E Ink and smart design, these portable reading devices closely mimics the size, weight, and feel of a book.
  • You may experience new dimension of reading, much like surfing the Internet — moving from content to content as your moods and needs changed.
  • They provide an convenient way of reading your favorite RSS feeds, or entire newspapers and popular magazines pages, or even to surf the web by using built-in Web browsers.
  • An electronic book reader can also play music and other multimedia files you import from your computer.
  • A wireless capability in some of e-book readers lets you access and purchase content remotely, wherever you are.
  • Very nice feature of some readers like Amazon Kindle is free access to the online encyclopedia (e.g.Wikipedia.org), meaning that you can get follow-up information, in real time, on any person, place or concept you happen to be reading about.
  • One substantial benefit of these reading devices is the ability to change the font size at will, for those who struggle with the font size used in many paper books.

Electronic Book Reader – Cons:

  • Ebook readers use various schemes of Digital Rights Management that may restrict your choice to book formats compatible with your chosen device.
  • For some users it is still not enjoyable to read from the reading device for any protracted period.
  • Missing the plethora of a comfort and enjoyment of an actual book.
  • The digital reader’s controls can be clumsy to use.
  • Paying hundreds of dollars for a device that will then allow you to buy e-books for an additional cost.
  • With real books, you can swap them with your friends or give them to charity shops when you’re finished with them. With electronic reading devices – you can not.

5 Electronic Book Readers that Rules the Market – in Matrix

Here is an overview of the best 2nd generation e-book readers, all based on E Ink technology:

Brandname HanLin eBook Sony PRS-700BC iRex Amazon’s Kindle 2 Bookeen
Model V3 PRS 700 Digital Reader 1000s D00511 Cybook Gen3
Manufacturer Jinke Electronics Sony iRex Technologies ? Netronix
Picture
Dimensions 184 × 120.5 × 9.9mm
(7.24″ × 4.74″ × .39″)
175 × 128 × 10 mm
(5.11 × 6.77 × 0.41″)
268 × 217 × 12 mm
(10.6″ × 8.5″ × .5″)
203 x 135 x 9mm
(8″ x 5.3″ x 0.36″)
188 × 118 × 8.5 mm
(7.4″ × 4.7″ × .3″)
Screen Technology EInk Vizplex EInk Vizplex EInk Vizplex E-Ink® electronic paper display EInk Vizplex
Primary Display (90 × 120mm) 6″ 600 × 800 pixels, 4 gray levels, 167 ppi (90 × 120mm) 6″ 600 × 800 pixels, 8 gray levels, 167 ppi (163×203mm) 10.2″ 1024×1280 pixels, 16 gray levels, 160 ppi (90 × 120mm) 6″ 600 × 800 pixels, 16 gray levels, 167 ppi (90 × 120mm) 6″ 600 × 800 pixels, 4 gray levels, 167 ppi
Secondary Display n.a. front light n.a. n.a. n.a.
Touch Screen n.a. yes (finger or stylus) yes (WaCom Pen, DR1000S & DR1000SW editions) keyboard n.a.
Full-screen Refresh Rate 0.9s ? 0.85s   0.9s
Power Li-ion 950mAh (Nokia Phone battery) Li-ion Li-ion 1300mAh Li-ion Li-Polymer 1000mAh
Battery Life 9′000 pages 7′500 pages claimed 24hrs(measured 8 hrs) with EVDO: “4 days”, without: “up to two week” 8′000 pages
Weight 200g (7.05oz) 283g (10oz) 570g (20.1oz) 289g (10.2oz) 174g (6.13oz)
OS Linux Linux 2.6.23 Linux 2.6.24 ? Linux
Boot Time 16s n.a. 50s   20s
SDK yes yes yes   ?
CPU Samsung Arm 9 200MHz Freescale i.MX31L (ARM1136JF-S core, 532MHz) Freescale i.MX31L 400MHz? ? Samsung S3C2410 (ARM920T 200MHz)
Memory 512MB, Internal 2M NOR Flash, 512MB SD Card included 128MB RAM, 512MB(NAND) Flash (~384MB user accessible) 128MB Ram + 1GB SD 2GB Flash (1.4GB user accessible) 16MB Ram, 8MB Rom + 512MB Flash
Expansion Slots SD/MMC MMC/SD/SDHC, Memory Stick Pro Duo SD/SDHC NONE SD
Other Interfaces USB 1.1, headphone USB 2.0, headphone USB 2.0 (charging), (1000SW only) WiFi 802.11b/g and Bluetooth USB 2.0 (charging), headphone, EVDO/CDMA USB 2.0 (charging), 2.5mm stereo
Supported Formats PDF, TXT, RTF, EPUB, LIT, PPT, WOLF, DOC, CHM, FB2, PRC/MOBI, HTML, DJVU, MP3, TIFF, JPG, GIF, BMP, PNG, RAR, ZIP BBeB (LRF/LRX), PDF, EPUB, TXT, RTF, JPG, BMP, GIF, PNG, MP3, AAC PDF, HTML, TXT, JPG, BMP, PNG, PRC/MOBI Kindle (AZW), TXT, Audible (formats 4, Audible Enhanced (AAX)), MP3, unprotected MOBI, PRC natively; PDF, HTML, DOC, JPEG, GIF, PNG, BMP through conversion. OEB-XHTML, TXT, HTML, PDF (non DRM), PRC/MOBI, JPG, GIF, PNG, MP3
Supported DRM Formats Wolf, MobiPocket Marlin DRM (BBeB), Adobe ADEPT (EPUB/PDF) MobiPocket AZW
(Kindle only,
USA only)
MobiPocket
Search functionality / Dictionary lookup no search using touchscreen using touchscreen using keyboard Dictionary lookup (using menus)
Note taking / highlighting / underlining no using touchscreen using touchscreen using keyboard bookmarks menu
Software WOLF Maker, WOLF Printer eBook Library, Adobe Digital Editions Paperless iRex Printer & Mobipocket Java Reader   Bookeen® Multi-format eBook reader
Services iStation, ReadMan Sony CONNECT iRex Technologies Delivery Service (iDS) Amazon Kindle Whispernet. E-mail conversion of DOC, HTML, JPEG, GIF, PNG, BMP and PDF
Content Partners MobiPocket Random House, Simon & Schuster, HarperCollins De Tijd, IFRA, Les Echos, NRC Handelsblad, MobiPocket Amazon MobiPocket, Ubibooks, Cluster21
Price US$299 US$399 US$649 US$359 US$350
Release Date Q3 2007 14 October 2008 mid-October 2008 Ordering began 02/09/08 Ordering began 28 Oct, 2007
Misc Info Company has been selling e-book devices since 2000 (V2 and V8 not shown).
V9 will have 9.7″ screen.
Sold under other names worldwide: lBook V3, DigiBook Reader V3, Apolo-Hanlin V3, Walkbook, Papyre 6.1, BEBOOK, Astak EZ Reader.
Company has been selling e-book devices since 2003 (PRS-500 not shown).
Originally only available in the US, now in Canada and the UK (PRS-505 only).
Company was established in 2001 as a Royal Philips Electronics spin-off.
Base DR1000 without touchscreen, DR1000S adds touchscreen.
DR1000WS adds WiFi and Bluetooth.
Annotations only exportable to Windows (and perhaps only for PDFs).
Amazon pays for the wireless connectivity for Kindle so there are no monthly wireless bills, data plans, or service commitments for customers.
Currently USA only.
Annotations stored in plain text files.
Sold directly by Bookeen, by BooksOnBoard.com in the US & Canada, and via wholesalers.
3rd generation Cybook (1st with E Ink).
Same hardware (EB-600) as STAReBOOK STK-101

Which Portable Ebook Reader is Best for Me?

All of these metrics, references and decisions… Let’s try to put it in plain English :)

If you read a lot of current books the ebook pricing is the best through Amazon (and you can buy content directly through the device). This is the biggest single advantage of Kindle as its bookstore is without doubt the most comprehensive of any.

The Cybook may be a better choice than the Kindle when it cams to a font style and size customization. The Kindle has one font and 6 font sizes. The Cybook has more sizes, and a larger maximum size. With Cybook, your can read in the font of your choice.

On the other side, Kindle is the only electronic book reader with a keyboard. It provides searching and annotation features that the Cybook and other readers doesn’t have. The Sony PRS-700 uses an on screen virtual keyboard where you have to click one letter at a time.

Another issue with short inches: Some PDF computer-books cannot open, crash or have too small print to read on readers with 6 inch screen like Sony, Hanlin and Cybook. (but a majority are readable)

If you prefer writing notes and annotations in your own hand writing, you should consider moving up to the iRex device, which has a digitizer pad that allows you this functionality.

Also, while the Sony PRS-700 has a highlight and note function, It has been reported that the Sony suffers dramatic slowdowns once you add more than a few annotations to a book.

Another advantage of Kindle 2 is in-line look-up to one dictionary (Oxford American dictionary is included), which is fast enough to be used routinely. It’s easy going from one word on the page to another and seeing the definition updated at the bottom of the page as you do so.

On Kindle’s downsides – It does not support PDF at all! It has to be converted to Mobi format (which the Kindle does support) – a process which may or may not work well.

The Sony does not have a backlight. An eInk screen is opaque, and hence cannot be backlit. What it does have is “side lighting” and a light diffuser over the screen which, inevitably, degrades the image quality somewhat, as does the touchscreen too.

Finally, you should be well aware of the warranty and accessibility issues before your opting. If you, for instance, buy a Sony in Australia, you will effectively be buying it with no warranty! In this case you should go for Kindle, Hanlin or CyBook.

Where Can I Buy It?

The Prospect of The EBook Readers Market

Digital book market is ignited. The critical mass of content is accomplished and you’ve got attractive hardware. Google is scanning millions of books from five of the world’s largest libraries and is about to make the contents searchable online. Amazon.com is moving aggressively into digital books, too. It sells digital versions of most of its titles, available for download instantly. With its Kindle 2.0 wireless reading device, you are a seconds away of your preferable reading wherever in the world you are.

After a few weeks of use, you may find yourself using the electronic book reader in ways you didn’t anticipate. Instead of reading a book all the way through, you are jumping around the content on the device, reading a newspaper on the train, a book during lunch, a Word file at work, a reference title when a question came up — whatever best fit the moment.

Finally, the electronic book readers pass the most crucial test for any gadget: The more you use it, the more useful you find it.




Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • Technorati
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • TwitThis

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

17 Comments

  1. Electronic Book Reader - Why, Which, Where? | Filesinfo.co.cc on 11.02.2009 at 20:19

    [...] Read the original post: Electronic Book Reader – Why, Which, Where? [...]

  2. Electronic Book Reader - Why, Which, Where? | StereoPropaganda on 11.02.2009 at 22:14

    [...] More here: Electronic Book Reader – Why, Which, Where? [...]

  3. Fashion Model (1 comments.) on 15.02.2009 at 09:48 (Reply)

    The OLPC’s XO Children’s Machine is in my oppinion an ultimate electronic book reader.

    Its greatest asset is the quality of its hardware. It’s beefy and difficult to damage. The battery lasts around six hours under normal use — not as long as the Kindle or Sony’s Reader, but comparable to newer netbooks.

    The XO’s screen was designed for high visibility with the backlight off, especially outdoors in daylight. You can also flip the screen around and put the XO into tablet mode. When you do, it’s comfortable to hold and scroll through pages using the keypads under your thumbs.

    Several open source projects, like Gutenberg.org are emerging that promise to improve the XO’s capability as an e-book reader.

    It’s cheap, too. When purchased through the Give 1, Get 1 program, costs $200 — cheaper than Amazon’s Kindle ($360) and Sony’s Reader ($270).

  4. karmin from beauty videos (1 comments.) on 02.03.2009 at 12:54 (Reply)

    Thanks for the breakdown on these e-book readers. My daughter loves to read and is not looking forward to the fact that she will not have a lot of space in her dorm room for her books. So she wants a kindle for her graduation gift from me. I only wish you could get college textbooks for it, that would be a real lifesaver.

  5. Bsd from pet snakes (1 comments.) on 05.03.2009 at 12:03 (Reply)

    A friend of mine had the original Kindle and lent it too me for a weekend. For the life of me I can’t figure out why anyone would want to use an electronic book instead of a real book. They are so foreign to the concept of a book that for the life of me I don’t understand how one can stand using them.

    1. andy from broadband(new comment) on 22.10.2009 at 13:09 (Reply)

      I used to also have the orig. Kindle… It took me a while to work out how to use it, but once I did it was pretty cool.

      @ Bsd (who said: For the life of me I can’t figure out why anyone would want to use an electronic book instead of a real book)…

      I think part of the appeal is being able to download books etc, and also read them on trains etc, without them getting bent and stuff……

  6. usua on 09.03.2009 at 10:41 (Reply)

    Hola además de la lista de sitios que propones yo he visto que venden en librerías.
    Podéis mirar en http://www.libreriacamara.com/pub/cam/asp/libros_electronicos.asp?op=20&c=88
    tiene varios modelos: Hanlin, Cybook, Iliad,…
    A mi me fue bien!!

  7. Buy Essay (1 comments.) on 07.04.2009 at 02:40 (Reply)

    The existence of ebook and the devices that supports ebooks have been rampant. I know that for some, it is better to have the actual book itself rather than read from the pc, laptop or ebook-support devices. But you see, these ebook devices are really helpful. It saves space that will be consumed by all the books that you have and it is handy – you can basically read a lot of ebooks anywhere and anytime that you want.

  8. Aspire One from cheap acer laptop (1 comments.) on 18.04.2009 at 19:40 (Reply)

    I am using a convertible tablet laptop as a book reader. The only annoying thing is narrow viewing angle and the heat, otherwise is pretty good and compatible with all possible file formats (html, mht, pdf, doc, help) since it runs windows xp

  9. Asif from Symbian Smartphone(new comment) on 06.05.2009 at 07:11 (Reply)

    My best pocket e-book reader is QuickOffice LM(Adobe Reader). An awesome mobile application that I use to read e-books with my nokia series 60 smartphone.

  10. Marco Gustafsson(new comment) on 19.06.2009 at 12:14 (Reply)

    Though Amazon.com is moving aggressively into digital books, Kindle is still a niche product, though of a high level and quality. In addition to mentioned advantages – is optimized to lessen eyestrain (can’t say this about PDAs and mobile phones). But Amazon should be more flexible with pricing of ebooks – either the pricing on Kindle titles will have to go down drastically or Amazon will have to develop a used eBook marketplace.

  11. tracy from child locator device(new comment) on 02.07.2009 at 19:01 (Reply)

    I got my daughter the kindle and she loves it! The books available online that are in public domain have done a great job of giving her some stuff to read.

  12. Anthony from THC Detox(new comment) on 12.07.2009 at 15:24 (Reply)

    that’s an interesting thing, only if they cost like, 20 bucks instead of 300 lol

  13. Andy from Salon Tools(new comment) on 25.08.2009 at 19:16 (Reply)

    For me, I’m all about the iPhone Kindle app. Much more portable, and plus it’s always on me, since it’s my phone. For $300, you have got to read a LOT of books.

  14. Sean Stickland(new comment) on 21.09.2009 at 06:30 (Reply)

    With the iPhone becoming more popular it seems that it just a software issue as the device itself is small enough to be carried around easily (it already is) and the screen is big enough to read easily enough.

    There are already a few application doing just this. I have only tried a few and the one I found best was Stanza.

    Interestingly, Lexcycle the company behind Stanza was bought by Amazon not so long ago. It will be interesting to see what developments will be made in the e-book front in the next few years.

  15. Tracy from medifast coupons(new comment) on 26.10.2009 at 18:21 (Reply)

    The kindle is amazing and you do not truly appreciate one until you have it. Now there are so many websites putting up public domain books in kindle format getting plenty to read does not have to cost a fortune.

  16. Donna Pabst(new comment) on 06.11.2009 at 02:19 (Reply)

    I am looking for a book reader for children I recently saw on TV, but can’t remember where I saw it. It is definitely for younger children and is said to have many picture books. If anyone has heard about it and can give me more information I would truly appreciate it.
    Donna

Leave a comment

This site uses KeywordLuv. Enter YourName@YourKeywords in the Name field to take advantage.